MARKETS / COMPANIES / ECONOMYRSS edition ↗
Dividend Outlook
Etfs

ETF fees are falling but that’s not the whole story

Core ETF charges continue to tumble, but the race to the bottom says as much about scale, distribution and product differentiation as it does about price.Average ongoing charges on equity UCITS ETFs have fallen 49 per…

ETF fees are falling but that’s not the whole story

Core ETF charges continue to tumble, but the race to the bottom says as much about scale, distribution and product differentiation as it does about price.

Average ongoing charges on equity UCITS ETFs have fallen 49 per cent since 2013. On fixed-income ETFs, they’re down 32 per cent. Some mainstream equity exposures now cost just three basis points.

This makes the narrative seem simple: amid a race to the bottom, ETFs are cheap. But the story is more complicated—and interesting—than that. 

Hector McNeil, co-founder and co-CEO of HANetf, calls the ‘ETFs are cheap’ line “misleading.” 

“ETFs became closely associated with low-cost passive investing because that was where much of the industry’s early growth took place. But an ETF is ultimately a wrapper. It does not tell you whether the underlying strategy should cost three basis points or 80 basis points,” he says. 

Of course, there’s scale. McNeil says the most intense price competition occurs in exposures investors view as largely interchangeable. If several ETFs offer essentially the same broad-market exposure, price becomes one of the few obvious ways to compete.

“If you are launching another broad equity tracker there are only so many ways to compete and price becomes one of the obvious ones. As a result, it is a difficult corner of the market for a new entrant to attack head-on,” he says. 

So the race to zero is partially a commoditisation story. 

Vanguard’s latest cut illustrates this part of the cost dynamic. The firm reduced ongoing costs on its FTSE All-World UCITS ETF again, to 0.14 per cent. A Vanguard spokesperson told ETF Express that the ETF “has seen strong investor demand and significant growth, allowing Vanguard to achieve greater scale.” In the world of relatively vanilla index tracking, scale matters and is, itself, a competitive advantage. 

But, as McNeil notes, this doesn’t mean only the biggest incumbent issuers can compete in broad beta. Large financial institutions may already have the client base and distribution channels that new issuers lack. “Rather than handing those assets to an incumbent provider, they can use a white-label platform to manufacture the exposure themselves and retain more of the economics within their own business,” he said. 

However, McNeil also pushes back on the idea that a mature or apparently commoditised exposure automatically has no room for innovation and can only compete on price. He points to a product that HANetf launched, The Royal Mint Responsibly Sourced Physical Gold ETC. 

McNeil explains that HANetf differentiated the product through its partnership with the Royal Mint, with the gold held in Royal Mint vaults outside the banking system, providing greater control over the underlying holdings. 

After Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, for example, the product was able to remove Russian-origin bars. It also introduced recycled gold through the Royal Mint’s precious metals recycling capabilities. McNeil says about 60 per cent of the ETC’s bars are certified 100 per cent recycled gold, which McNeil claims, can be 90 per cent less carbon intensive than mined gold, making the product potentially more attractive to sustainably-minded investors. 

The product isn’t the cheapest gold product on the market, but its features have helped it grow to around USD1.5 billion in assets. 

“There can still be room to compete if you create genuine differentiation rather than simply trying to be one basis point cheaper,” McNeil says. “In fact, I don’t think the ETC would have grown to the size it was had we simply tried to just compete on price.” 

So sometimes product design and features can differentiate even in seemingly mature exposures.  

Thematic and active ETFs are a separate case because differentiation is built much more naturally into the product. 

With thematic ETFs, McNeil says first-mover advantage can matter, but so can the quality of the research and index construction behind a strategy. A large issuer might offer a thematic ETF at a lower cost, but a smaller issuer can still compete if it’s able to show investors a more thoughtful methodology.

Active ETFs take that logic further. 

“With active management, the product is inherently differentiated,” McNeil says. “Investors are paying for the manager, the investment process, the team, the track record and the firm’s expertise.” 

The ETFs are cheap and getting cheaper headlines only tell part of the story. 

The most intense price competition happens in products where investors can’t identify a meaningful difference between funds. Here, scale can help eliminate a few basis points and attract more inflows. Elsewhere, distribution, product design, methodology or active management can provide competitive advantages and help justify higher costs. 

While the ETF fee war is real, it isn’t being fought the same way across every product. As more strategies—and innovative twists on longstanding exposures—use the wrapper, the question comes back to something ETF Express has focused on in recent weeks: cost matters, but so does whether an ETF does a distinct job—or complements one already being done—in a portfolio.

Source: ETF Express — ETF Industry News ↗

Figures reflect the source report and its stated period. This article is for information and is not investment advice.